Keep the practice running through the doubt. Certainty arrives behind it.

संदेह में भी जप चलता रहे, निश्चय बाद में आता है।

On wavering faith, which he treats as ordinary rather than shameful. Certainty comes after the practice, not before it.

Premanand Ji Maharaj during satsang at Shri Hit Radha Keli Kunj, Vrindavan
What it means

Keep going through the doubt

Doubt arrives in every long practice, and he does not treat it as a spiritual emergency. Sooner or later a devotee wonders whether any of this is true, whether the years have been spent on nothing, and whether the people around them at satsang have simply agreed to believe something together. He has heard it many times and he does not react to it as a betrayal.

What he refuses is the demand hidden inside it. Devotees want the doubt resolved before they will continue, and they want the resolution to come from him, in the form of an argument or a proof. He declines to supply that. Certainty produced by somebody else's reasoning lasts until a better argument comes along, which is not a foundation anybody should build a practice on.

His instruction is to let the doubt run and keep the practice running underneath it. The two can coexist; they do coexist, in most people, for long stretches. Nothing about taking the name requires you to have first settled a metaphysical question, and waiting for the question to settle guarantees only that the years pass without practice as well as without an answer.

In practice

Living with this saying

He points out where the certainty people eventually have actually came from, and it is never an argument. It came from a long stretch of continuing, and from noticing afterwards that they had become someone they were not before: slower to anger, easier to live with, less afraid of the night hours. That is evidence of a kind, gathered from your own life, and it is not available to somebody who stopped in order to think.

There is also a practical observation about when doubt tends to appear. It arrives most reliably during dry periods, exhaustion, and after a loss, which are precisely the times judgement is least reliable. He is not saying the doubt is illegitimate. He is saying that the hour it turns up in is a poor hour for making a permanent decision, and permanent decisions is what people want to make in it.

What it asks of you is to separate two things that feel like one. You are not required to believe anything today. You are only required to do the same small thing you did yesterday, while the question stays open for as long as it stays open. If an answer arrives it will arrive behind the practice rather than in front of it, which is the order he says it always comes in.

A saying, not a certified transcription: a short statement of a position he has taken consistently in public satsang.

About this saying

Questions about this saying

What does Premanand Ji Maharaj mean by “Keep the practice running through the doubt. Certainty arrives behind it”?

On wavering faith, which he treats as ordinary rather than shameful. Certainty comes after the practice, not before it.

What is this saying in Hindi?

संदेह में भी जप चलता रहे, निश्चय बाद में आता है।

Is this an exact quotation?

No. It is a short statement of a position he has taken consistently in public satsang, not a certified transcription of one recording.

Where can I hear him speak about this?

His satsang is recorded and published on the official channels. This site is an independent devotee site and is not connected to the ashram.

Keep reading

All 30 sayings

The Radha naam is itself the greatest mantra. God is not a judge waiting to punish you. The mind is not your enemy, it is only untrained. Do not give anger a second thought. Do the work fully, then hand the result over. Suffering is the distance between what happened and what you demanded. Service done to be seen is a transaction. You do not need to leave home. Do your sadhana inside it. Keep taking the name even when you feel nothing. Difficulty does not mean you have taken a wrong turn. The name can be taken anywhere. Nobody's permission is needed. Take only as much of the name as you can keep up daily. When you are ill, go to the doctor. Take the name alongside. What changes first is your conduct, not your feelings. Do not hand the mind the problem. Hand it the name. Do not weigh your life against one you only see from outside. The one who wronged you moved on. You are the one still paying rent. Children copy what is done and ignore what is said. Devotion that creates conflict at home has misunderstood itself. If it can be bought, it has nothing to do with me. Begin with the name. Study will follow the practice. Keep the practice running through the doubt. Certainty arrives behind it. With the name in your mouth you are never in an empty room. Put the mala where the phone used to be. Earn honestly, spend without cruelty, give quietly. The relationship does not end when the body does. Fix the routine before you try to fix the mind. Do your own part fully and stop keeping accounts of the other person's. The gap between what happens and how you react is the first real result. One instruction heard two hundred times gets acted on. Two hundred heard once do not.